Can I Refuse To Rent To Someone Based On Their Pet Ownership?

As a landlord in Ontario, understanding pet ownership’s legalities is crucial for compliant property management. Under the Ontario Rental Guidelines 2024, landlords generally cannot refuse to rent to someone solely because they have a pet. This protection ensures that tenants with pets are not unfairly discriminated against during the rental process.

However, there are specific exceptions to this rule. If the rental property is a condominium, there may be specific pet restrictions outlined in the condominium bylaws that tenants must adhere to. These bylaws can include limitations on the size, type, or number of pets allowed within the unit. In such cases, landlords can refuse a tenant’s application if their pet does not comply with these established condominium rules.

Additionally, landlords can refuse to rent to tenants with pets if the pet poses a safety risk or causes significant disturbances. For instance, if a pet is known to be aggressive, has a history of causing damage, or consistently creates excessive noise, the landlord may have grounds to deny the rental application. This exception aims to protect the property and the well-being of other tenants or neighbours.

Landlords must handle these situations carefully and document any specific concerns related to the pet. Blanket pet policies that automatically reject tenants with pets can lead to legal challenges and potential human rights complaints. Instead, evaluating each situation on a case-by-case basis, considering the pet’s behaviour, and adhering to the guidelines set forth by condominium bylaws or safety concerns will ensure a fair and lawful approach.

Maintaining transparency and clear communication with potential tenants about pet policies can also help avoid misunderstandings and foster a positive landlord-tenant relationship. Including specific pet-related clauses in the lease agreement, such as responsibilities for damages or noise, can further protect the landlord’s interest while accommodating pet owners.

By following the Ontario Rental Guidelines 2024 and thoughtfully considering exceptions, landlords can navigate the complexities of renting to tenants with pets. This approach not only ensures legal compliance but also supports a diverse and inclusive rental market, enhancing the reputation and attractiveness of the rental property.

Did you find this useful?