Should I Rent Out My Property Instead Of Selling It?

Renting out your Toronto property can provide steady income, but selling may deliver stronger returns depending on market conditions and your goals.

For many homeowners, the decision to rent or sell comes down to timing, financial strategy, and personal circumstances. Toronto’s real estate market is diverse, with downtown condos averaging around $700K and detached homes often trading above $1.5M (TRREB, 2025). That scale means your choice can significantly affect both cash flow and long-term equity.

When Renting Makes Sense

If you don’t need immediate access to your equity, renting can provide a stable monthly income. Downtown condos near transit lines often rent quickly, and rental demand in neighbourhoods like Liberty Village, The Annex, or Leslieville remains strong. Rental income may offset carrying costs, but landlords must also budget for repairs, vacancies, and property management.

• Cash Flow Potential: Strong rental demand across neighbourhoods like Liberty Village, Leslieville, and The Annex means well-located properties can provide consistent income.
• Holding for Appreciation: Renting allows you to wait for long-term market growth while tenants help cover carrying costs.
• Flexibility: If you expect to return to Toronto or want to maintain a presence in the market, renting preserves your options.

When Selling Makes Sense

Selling may be better if you want liquidity, plan to buy another property, or feel the market has reached a peak. Detached homes in desirable neighbourhoods often sell at a premium, especially if supply is tight. A sale also avoids the responsibilities of being a landlord, including tenant laws and maintenance obligations.

• Unlocking Equity: Selling a property frees up capital to buy another, invest elsewhere, or reduce debt.
• Avoiding Landlord Obligations: Tenancy laws in Ontario can be strict, and managing repairs, vacancies, or disputes can be stressful.
• Maximizing ROI Today: In specific neighbourhoods, buyer demand for freeholds or move-in-ready condos may create stronger offers than holding as a rental

Financial Considerations

• Capital Gains: Primary residences are exempt from capital gains tax, but investment properties are not.
• Mortgage Rules: Check with your lender to confirm whether your mortgage allows rental use or whether a refinance is needed.
• Cash Flow vs. Equity: Renting is a long-term play, while selling provides immediate access to capital that can be reinvested elsewhere.

The Fox Marin Real Estate Team has guided more than 1,000 Toronto sellers and investors. Our process includes rental market analysis, TRREB pricing data, and financial modelling to help you decide whether renting or selling maximizes your return.

Key takeaway: Renting generates ongoing income, while selling offers liquidity and certainty. The right choice depends on your financial goals and Toronto market conditions.

Did you find this useful?